Successful transformation must be a constant
A
lbert Einstein once very appropriately said, “We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them.” This quote resonated deeply during a recent conversation with leaders from a community I’ve been consulting with. Their persistent refrain was, “We are just different from other communities,” suggesting their challenges were uniquely insurmountable.
This mindset is remarkably common. According to a 2023 National Main Street Center survey, 78% of community leaders initially believed their problems were unique, yet after collaborative workshops, 92% acknowledged fundamental similarities in their core challenges. This data confirms what I’ve observed across hundreds of communities: the perception of uniqueness often serves as a psychological barrier to change rather than reflecting reality.
The evidence is compelling. When examining 150 successful community revitalizations over the past decade, the Brookings Institution found that 85% followed similar transformation pathways despite varying starting points. The communities ranged from rural towns of 2,500 to mid-sized cities of 150,000, with economic diversity spanning former manufacturing hubs to agricultural centers.
Consider Emporia, Kansas (population 24,000) and Paducah, Kentucky (population 27,000). Despite different geographic and economic profiles, both transformed their downtowns through similar strategic approaches, resulting in 30% and 35% increases in downtown occupancy respectively over five years. The difference wasn’t in their problems or solutions but in their execution and commitment.
The pathway to community transformation isn’t on the road less traveled. It follows a well-established highway with clear signage and proven exit strategies. Yes, communities face different obstacles, but successful transformation invariably requires navigating the same critical passages. The real question isn’t whether the roadmap works—it’s where your community enters the journey.
Some communities start with higher poverty rates—the national average for small towns hovers around 16%, but some communities I’ve worked with face rates exceeding 25%. Others benefit from corporate headquarters providing financial leverage, with corporate philanthropy accounting for an average of 18% of community development funding in such towns. Some communities boast volunteer engagement rates of 35% compared to the national average of 25%, giving them a head start in community-driven initiatives.
Despite these varying starting points, the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston’s research on 67 revitalized communities found that 74% implemented remarkably similar strategic frameworks regardless of their initial conditions. Success wasn’t determined by starting resources but by effectively deploying whatever resources were available. What are these common transformation elements? First, every successful revitalization begins with abandoning outdated thinking. The communities that thrived were those willing to embrace change, with 88% of successful transformations involving significant shifts in local planning paradigms.
Second, they cultivate robust volunteer networks. Communities with volunteer rates exceeding the national average by just 5% showed transformation timelines shortened by an average of 2.3 years. Third, they actively foster entrepreneurship, with successful communities averaging 12% higher rates of new business formation than stagnant ones.
Fourth, they forge partnerships between municipal leadership and private sector champions, creating accountability systems where both sectors balance responsibilities. Fifth, they develop transparent communication networks—communities implementing multi-channel communication strategies experienced 40% better resident buy-in for revitalization projects.
Sixth, they understand the economic multiplier effect of supporting locally-owned businesses. Research shows that for every $100 spent at local businesses, $68 remains in the local economy versus just $43 from chain stores. Finally, they cultivate a truly-local mindset among residents, with community education programs resulting in measurable shifts in local spending habits—typically 8-12% increases in local commerce within 18 months.
Every community has challenges, but the notion that yours faces unique problems no other community has encountered is statistically improbable and intellectually limiting. Of the nearly 20,000 incorporated places in the United States, patterns of challenge and opportunity repeat with remarkable consistency. Every community has within its DNA the ability to transform. While major projects eventually require capital investment, lack of money need not be the initial barrier. The Knight Foundation found that 62% of transformative community projects began with minimal funding but secured substantial investment after demonstrating early wins and community commitment.
As Norman Vincent Peale wisely noted, “Empty pockets never held anyone back. Only empty heads and empty hearts can do that.” The data overwhelmingly supports this sentiment—the communities that transform aren’t necessarily the wealthiest, but invariably they’re the ones that refuse to accept limitation as their destiny.
John A. Newby is the author of the “Building Main Street, Not Wall Street” column dedicated to helping communities and local media companies combine synergies allowing them to thrive in a world where truly-local is being lost to Amazon and Wall Street chains. His email: john@360MediaAlliance.net